Two Arm & Hammer bags, two different cleanup jobs
These two products share a brand and a baking-soda odor-control story, but they are not interchangeable refills. One is built for a swivel bin used to pick up pet waste; the other is a refill for the Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-in-1 Litter Scoop waste bag holder and is aimed at litter box cleanup. The useful comparison is not which bag is better in general, but which one fits the holder and the mess you are actually dealing with.
What each bag is designed to do
- Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags: Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags are described as strong and durable, with easy-tie handles, and they help keep bins clean. The easy-tie handles and bin-focused design point to scooping and disposing of pet waste rather than lining a litter scoop.
Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags - Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills: Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills are described as making it easy to dispose of litter box contents. This refill is specifically tied to litter box cleanup, so it suits a different task than the swivel bin bags.

Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills
Holder fit is the deciding factor
The supplied records do not list universal bag dimensions or a cross-compatibility chart, so the safest approach is to match each refill to the holder it was described for.
- Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags: The instructions describe pulling a single bag from the perforated side of the package, looping the bag handles around molded hooks on the side of the bin, then unhooking and tying the handles for disposal. That points to a swivel bin with side hooks.
- Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills: The record states these bags are designed to fit perfectly with the Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-in-1 Litter Scoop waste bag holder. No equivalent fit claim is supplied for the swivel bin.
- What is not confirmed: The supplied information does not confirm that either bag fits the other product's holder. Treat any swap as unverified until the holder and refill are checked against each other.
Odor control and pack details
- Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags: The Swivel Bin bags use a fresh scent and activated baking soda to control natural odors. This is the odor-control claim supplied for the bin-style bag, useful if smell is your main concern during scooping.
- Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills: Each Deluxe 2-In-1 refill bag is infused with Arm & Hammer Baking Soda, described as a natural odor neutralizer with a soft scent to mask unpleasant odors. The litter scoop refill has its own baking-soda odor approach, so you are not choosing between scented and unscented here.
- Arm & Hammer Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills: The Deluxe 2-In-1 refill comes as 45 bags in assorted colors. That gives you a concrete count for planning litter box refills; the supplied Swivel Bin record lists a 20 pack in the Penny color option.
- Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags: The supplied Swivel Bin variant evidence shows a 20 pack in the Penny color option. Pack size and color are listed for this option, but the record does not establish how many bags other color or size options contain.
Choose by the holder you already own
- If you use a swivel bin with side hooks: The Arm & Hammer Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags are the refill with supplied instructions for looping handles around molded hooks on the bin. They are the better-documented match for that setup.
- If you use the Deluxe 2-in-1 Litter Scoop holder: The Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills are the refill explicitly described as fitting that holder, and they are sold in a 45-count assorted-color pack.
- If you are buying for both setups: Keep the two refills separate. The evidence supports each bag for its own holder, not as a shared refill for both.
- If you are unsure which holder you have: Check for side hooks and the swivel-bin shape versus the Deluxe 2-in-1 Litter Scoop holder before ordering. The supplied records do not provide bag measurements you could use to confirm a cross-fit.
The practical takeaway
For litter box cleanup with the Deluxe 2-in-1 Litter Scoop holder, the Deluxe 2-In-1 Litter Scoop Waste Bag Refills are the direct refill, with 45 baking-soda-infused bags in assorted colors. For scooping pet waste into a swivel bin with side hooks, the Swivel Bin Pet Waste Bags are the refill with matching loading and tying instructions, a fresh scent, and activated baking soda.
The honest limitation is compatibility: the supplied information does not confirm that either bag works in the other holder. Choose the refill that matches your holder first, then use the scent and pack details to decide between available options.




